Cost analysis is a critical element in the army acquisition process. Analysis of the operational costs of trucking, an annual report aimed at providing more accurate marginal cost data on motor carrier operations. These predictions are based on the condition of the equipment that is evaluated based on the data gathered through the use of various condition monitoring. Preventive and corrective maintenance cost comparison.
Most of nff will be avoided by expert system, thus a costeffective and timely fault diagnosis will help to. Preventive and corrective maintenance cost comparison and. Office of inspector general page 3 analysis of fleet replacement lifecycle implement and is often as much an art as science. These methods lack the ability of identifying the h idden. The guidelines for life cycle cost analysis lcca instruct project. Modelling and analysis of rail maintenance cost sciencedirect.
Introduction buell and smedley 1 define lean manufacturing as a systematic approach to identifying and eliminating waste through continuous improvement. Preventive and corrective maintenance cost comparison and costbenefit analysis article in structure and infrastructure engineering 125 may 2015 with 2,830 reads how we measure reads. Backup power cost of ownership analysis and incumbent. This would lead to an optimal time of replacement analysis based on the total cost of maintenance. The probability density function pdf that describes the probability that the equipment will fail due to a particular failure cause.
Mar 02, 2016 zero emission bus manufacturers regularly include estimates of maintenance cost savings in total cost of ownership comparisons to conventional buses. Tools for improving maintenance strategies and failure analysis processes. The amount of time that the equipment is expected to be down each time corrective maintenance is required. Comparing maintenance strategies based on cost and. Construction, rehabilitation and user costs are included in the model.
This 2016 maintenance operations and performance analysis report mopar builds on ncgs 644. Backup power cost of ownership analysis and incumbent technology comparison j. This combined cost was again published for a wide variety of machines as a percentage of new cost for both the total cost during wearout life and the average cost per 100 hours of use. Full cost accounting for municipal solid waste management. Also, the manual provides a framework for the development, documentation, and presentation of force cost estimates. Costs of submarine maintenance at public and private shipyards.
An analysis of maintenance strategies and development of a model for strategy formulation a case study master of science thesis in the master degree programme, production engineering. Wurzbach maintenance reliability group, 2 highland lane, suite 100, brogue, pa 17309. Repair and maintenance cost analysis of tractors and combines. Equipment lifecycle cost analysis lcca is typically used as one component of the equipment fleet management process and allows the fleet manager to make repair,equipment replacement, and retention decisions on the basis of a given piece of equipments economic life. From the analysis it is observed that the costmeter is higher for curves without lubrication.
Case studies, presented in boxes throughout the handbook, provide snapshots of how other communities across the country. Pdf analysis of buildings operation and maintenance costs. Leveraging the general assemblys lead, the department engaged in a concerted. Recently, battery electric bus manufacturers, including byd, new flyer, and proterra, indicate there are substantial maintenance cost savings with battery electric buses compared to conventional.
Using weibull analysis to plan maintenance machine design. A webbased cost benefit analysis method for predictive. Life cycle cost analysis of asphalt and concrete pavements final. Qds101 operating and maintenance cost estimating guidelines revision. An analysis of maintenance strategies and development of a. A webbased cost benefit analysis method for predictive maintenance richard n. Preventive maintenance, waste elimination, activities, frequency, analysis, cost reduction. This manual contains useful information for those who help in providing data for cost analysis purposes. Roadway costs include the cost of land, construction, financing, maintenance and operations. Most of nff will be avoided by expert system, thus a cost effective and timely fault diagnosis will help to reduce dmc. However, the formulation of a maintenance strategy depends on a number of factors, including the cost of down time, reliability characteristics and redundancy of assets. This measure can vary greatly by interpretation of what is or is not included. Tools for improving maintenance strategies and failure. A behaviorbased approach by sam mcnair, pe, cmrp, life cycle engineering page 3 of 7 when looking at maintenance costs, the most important concept that you must remember is that your organizations behaviors change the resulting cost numbers.
Transportation cost and benefit analysis ii vehicle costs victoria transport policy institute. Predictive maintenance is a proactive maintenance strategy that tries to predict when a piece of equipment might fail so that maintenance work can be performed just before that happens. To improve the costeffectiveness of its building and renovation programs, stanford must invest in designs and systems with improved longterm performance. Jan 19, 2017 an effective preventive maintenance software system would follow the 8020 pareto principle with either cm or pm taking up 80% of the maintenance costs and time. Costbenefit factors influencing preventive maintenance strategy. Pump station and rising mains maintenance costs are the same for both options 20 yr life cycle cost period with a 7% discount rate. The research presented in the paper is aimed at determining possibilities for collecting historic data on the maintenance and use of buildings of the josip juraj strossmayer university in osijek. The asset maintenance cost analysis divides the cost per unit of usage, such as run time hours or miles driven into the maintenance cost per vehicle. Pdf building maintenance cost planning and estimating. Program at embryriddle aeronautical university, usa.
The opportunity cost of roadway land is included in chapter 5. Obsolescence life and wearout life of each machine were given with some revision. An indication of whether the failure is detectable during normal operation. Maintenance costs are dependent on multiple variables including vehicle age, duty cycle, topography, fleet maintenance practices and several other factors. Over time, this has come to include multiple wordings that describe various cost. Analysis on costs for aircraft maintenance 181 seen as a way to address the difficulty. Pdf how can airplane operators reduce maintenance cost. Youll learn how to assemble necessary data, calculate full cost information from the available data, and report the results of your fca analysis to government officials and residents.
Waste is further defined as anything that adds no value to the manufacturing process. Maintenance and service costs of commercial building ground. Each companys needs are different and a costbenefit analysis cba should be run before a strategy is selected. Maintenance can represent a significant portion of the cost in asset intensive organisations, as breakdowns have an impact on the capacity, quality and cost of operation. One major assumption implicit in the lifecycle approach is that future maintenance and repair costs can be forecasted with. Repair costs are generally 10 to 15% of the total annual cost, but because they tend to increase with machine age, repair costs become important in influencing the optimal time of machinery replacement rotz, 1985. Ainscough national renewable energy laboratory nrel is a national laboratory of the u. A 6% discount rate is used for the base case scenario, and the allowed rut depth is 3. Non maintenance related downtime may be attributed to lack of demand, an interruption in raw material supply or production scheduling delays beyond the control of the maintenance function. When purchasing an item that requires upkeep, consumers should consider not just the initial. An analysis period of 40 years was chosen for this project. The costs incurred to keep an item in good condition andor good working order. Airline operating costs dot form 41 traffic, financial, and operating cost data reported to the dot by us major airlines data is reported and published quarterly for most tables. Asset utilization is also a function of operating rate, quality and yield losses, etc.
Sensitivity analysis required at discount rates of 4% and 10%. Predictive maintenance is the complement of preventive maintenance. In addition, the track maintenance costs esti mated by traditional accountingbased methods do not provide the transportation and engineering planners with inputs concerning the track maintenance cost. Typical bus maintenance costs when evaluating different studies, the key to interpreting results is understanding general trends that affect maintenance costs. Survey questionnaire and approach the detailed survey questionnaire included a preamble explaining the importance of the survey to the groundsource maintenance and service costs of commercial building. The most basic measure of maintenance cost is a sum of extracted components from a manufacturing cost sheet, and is simply total maintenance cost. The technical meaning of maintenance involves functional checks, servicing, repairing or replacing of necessary devices, equipment, machinery, building infrastructure, and supporting utilities in industrial, business, governmental, and residential installations. Benefitcost analysis of road maintenance or a dollar in time saves nine andrew carter and sarah olmstead department of policy and evaluation millennium challenge corporation. The current american society of agricultural engineers asae recommendations for estimating repair costs are based upon forty years. Section 3 presents methodology used to estimate metro transits annual bus operating expenses for the project alternatives. Through the utilization of various nondestructive testing and measuring techniques, predictive maintenance determines equipment status before a breakdown occurs. Abstract accurate and believable cost benefit analysis is critical to the success of predictive maintenance programs. With predictive devices currently available, it is incumbent upon. It supports management decisions by quantifying the resource impact of alternative options.
486 1528 965 512 746 1424 196 1569 1018 296 909 732 645 358 1422 384 652 1498 1543 764 1076 1004 107 549 1444 224 1171 268 1168 1195