Ncaa responds to courts ruling regarding ed obannon lawsuit in a decision issued friday, u. In the obannon antitrust case against the national collegiate athletic. A cinderella story meghan rose price follow this and additional works at. Judge claudia wilkens 99page decision issued a resounding rebuke to the foundation of the n. This casenote is brought to you for free and open access by villanova. National collegiate athletic association villanova. In contrast, courts consider the vast majority of agreements under the rule of reason. The lawsuit, which former ucla basketball player ed obannon filed on behalf of the ncaas division i football and mens basketball players, challenges the organizations use of the images of its former student athletes for commercial purposes.
Mar 24, 2017 ed obannon originally brought his case in 2009 in the united states district court for the northern district of california. United states district court for the northern district of california 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 year between 1997. The potential unintended consequences of the obannon decision. Source document contributed to documentcloud by pg newsroom pittsburgh post gazette. Aug 08, 2014 obannon decision signals the end of the collegiate model in the wake of fridays landmark obannon decision, its time to ask, just what does the ncaa do.
O bannons case has gained momentum in recent months. As supreme court declines to hear obannon case, focus turns. Oct 11, 2015 obannon has received significant attention. This note is brought to you for free and open access by scholarship commons. District judge claudia wilken ruled in favor of former ucla basketball player ed obannon and 19 others in a lawsuit that challenged the ncaas regulation of college athletics on antitrust grounds. Volante first of all, under the rule of reason, in this court and in the supreme court, to be valid, a restraint need only be reasonably necessary to achieve the procompetitive ends. The ninth circuits september 2015 obannon decision precludes players claims in multidistrict litigation against the ncaa and nearly a dozen athletic conferences over allegedly anti. In 2008, ed obannon, a former allamerican basketball player at ucla, visited a. Ncaa 29 collegiate athletic association ncaa rules that limited studentathlete scholarships and prohibited studentathletes from receiving compensation for the use of their names, images, and likenesses. Obannon united states court of appeals for the ninth circuit. Part of the antitrust and trade regulation commons, and the entertainment, arts, and sports law commons recommended citation meghan r. National collegiate athletic association, aka the ncaa, defendantappellant, and electronic arts, inc collegiate licensing company, aka clc, defendants. A federal judge today denied the ncaas request to dismiss the ed o bannon antitrust lawsuit and concluded that a 1984 u.
District judge claudia wilken is about to preside over a second college sports trial that could be a gamechanger. Until the appellate court issues its decision, however, it is too early to speculate what further appeals, if any, the ncaa might seek. Ed obannon plaintiffs ask supreme court to take ncaa case. This story has grown out of other stories i have heard or read that always put me in mind of the obannon castle back in the old days of ireland. Problem solving models are used to address the many challenges that arise in the workplace. Not for publication united states court of appeals for. Why and how the supreme court should have decided obannon. When a story comes to mind it often takes a life of its own and becomes something greater than the author envisioned. Registration please be advised that on behalf of the commissioner of the department of environmental management, i have issued a decision regarding the enclosed matter. This casenote is brought to you for free and open access by.
A collective class, held together over the issue of a faulty product, suing a defendant, or a band of defendants, multiple negligent companies, as an example, being sued by a single person. Schools were also free to hire nonstudent ringers to. Despite defeating the ncaa in federal court, ed o bannon s trial win seems to be a victory in name only. August 11, 2014 how ncaa ruling helps case for raised. Antitrust applies without limitation to sports in general. Aug 08, 2014 the injunction, prompted by the ed o bannon suit, is perhaps the most important ruling in the history of the ncaa, as it will put a stop to the organizations refusal to allow athletes to make any. The plaintiffs represented to the district court that they had, to the extent possible, excised from their fee request hours spent on unrelated claims, and. We conclude that the district courts decision was largely correct. Board of regents, universities and conferences were free to make their own business. As discussed below, the legislature has provided that a small percentage of students who meet certain.
The potential unintended consequences of the obannon. Straddling the intersection of antitrust, intellectual property, and sports law, the case presents engaging and complex issues. The six step problem solving model free management books. Obannonncaa case takes a twist in filing with supreme court. Oct 04, 2016 the supreme courts decision not to hear the obannon case protects college sports amateurism model for now, but earlier ruling that the association violates antitrust laws leaves the model as supreme court declines to hear obannon case, focus turns to other antitrust lawsuits against ncaa. The decision was limited to football and mens basketball playersas opposed to nonrevenuegenerating sports. Ninth circuits recent decision in obannon that refused to recognize a quasiexemption from antitrust law for ncaa regulation of studentathletes. The court noted that the decision obtained by plaintiffs is the first by any federal court to hold that any aspect of the ncaas amateurism rules violate the antitrust laws, let alone to mandate by injunction that the ncaa change its. A conversation with college sports trailblazer ed obannon. Obannon trial decision changes everything but preserves the. Obannon has created five original television series farscape, seaquest dsv, defiance, cult, and alien nation. Obannon made his writing debut selling spec material to nbcs amazing stories 1985 and cbss the twilight zone 1985, but first garnered critical. Ncaa 3 the panel held that it was not precluded from reaching the merits of plaintiffs sherman act claim because.
The ninth circuit, which decided the obannon appeal, declared the case momentous. He was challenging the rules that prohibit student athletes from receiving a share of the revenue that the ncaa receives from the sale of licenses to use student athletes names, images, and likenesses. This article is brought to you for free and open access by the journals at. A federal judge today denied the ncaas request to dismiss the ed obannon antitrust lawsuit and concluded that a 1984 u. As supreme court declines to hear obannon case, focus. What is the o bannon lawsuit as a general overview, class action lawsuits involve a large group of people in some capacity.
Former ncaa athletes led by former basketball star ed o bannon jr. Ninth circuit should affirm obannon 303 there is no good reason why antitrust law cannot apply to the ncaa. At the same time, the court took only an incremental step in the direction of pay for college athletes. Ncaa, the first federal appellate court decision holding that an ncaa studentathlete eligibility rule violates section 1 of the sherman act. While many people regularly solve problems, there are a range of different approaches that can be used to find a solution. Obannon trial decision changes everything but preserves. The obannon decision made a significant change to one of the philosophical pillars of intercollegiate athletics in allowing for greater compensation for student athletes. Ncaa indicated that all college sports are not equal in economic value. D4afph4w any given athletic director knows that his schools. Regular lobby hours will resume at all o bannon bank facilities may 11, 2020. Jul 08, 2016 the ed obannon antitrust case against the ncaa already uncommon in generating competing requests for hearing by the supreme court has taken another unusual turn in its filings with the.
The obannon decision dealt a blow to the ncaas notion of amateurism and marked the ncaas first significant courtroom defeat since 1984. While part iv of form 3a, and preceding forms, has been omitted from the current version, this analysis is still relevant for two reasons. Bannon decision by analyzing form 3a for unconscionability with regards to the ncaas policies on the use of a student athletes nil. On behalf of a class of studentathletes, former college basketball star ed obannon sued the ncaa, challenging rules that prohibited payment for the use of names, images, and likenesses nils in videogames, live game telecasts, and other footage. The obannon decision is an important step forward for both collegeathletes rights and sports law jurisprudence because it recognizes that ncaa rules limiting collegeathlete pay may violate section 1 of the sherman antitrust act. Ncaa says obannon thwarts quick win bid in antitrust row. The obannon decision dealt a blow to the ncaas notion of am.
Despite defeating the ncaa in federal court, ed obannons trial win seems to be a victory in name only. S circuit court of appeals will overturn the district courts order to the contrary. The ninth circuit decision in obannon and the fallacy of. What is the o bannon lawsuit justice matters action center. This note is brought to you for free and open access by scholarship. The decision, if made by a professional, is presumptively valid.
The court noted that the decision obtained by plaintiffs is the first by any federal court to hold that any aspect of the ncaas amateurism rules violate the antitrust laws, let alone to mandate by injunction that the ncaa change its practices. Former ncaa athletes led by former basketball star ed obannon jr. In it, obannon details not just the road to and through the courtroom that led to the landmark decision, but also his own 12point call to action to fix the broken college sports system in the u. Why and how the supreme court should have decided obannon v. The article concludes with a discussion of what may ensue in obannon, if anything, and in both jenkins v. Obannon decision signals the end of the collegiate model. Obannon is an american television writer, screenwriter and producer, working primarily in the science fiction genre. Ncaa is an antitrust class action lawsuit filed against the national collegiate athletic association ncaa. Mar 18, 20 a quick look at the big changes coming from the o bannon trial over image likeness and how they could alter the landscape of college sports.
1351 14 803 301 537 895 290 464 293 1383 583 911 92 902 1060 255 167 1278 354 152 1411 1348 723 1203 1392 999 965 1363 613 1173 1063 686 994 666 42 626 669 575 309 619 342 481 575 1470 1086 1353